Mainstream parenting, compulsory schooling and organized religion
share a common goal – conditioning, modifying and training the
hearts and minds of children – quoting Alice Miller, for
their own
good, of course. To accomplish this each and most every other
cultural institution employ the same tactics – comparison, threats,
praise, punishment and rewards, done primarily to maintain that
institution’s place in the social order – often at the expense of the
child’s true development.
The spinal tap of these high stakes strategies reaches deep inside
and gains power by triggering our most primal survival reflex – fear of not being wanted,
rejection and abandonment, for life is relationship. Not being related is suicidal.
But what is it that is being compared, praised and rejected? It is the image we create
and maintain about our self and this image reflects our status in the prevailing culture
just as the cultural institution maintains its position by conforming to its image.
Everything is caught in the same net and remains caught by identifying itself with its
cultural image. And in the struggle to live up to that image - we forget it is an image.
New human beings are born prematurely, compared to other species, to accommodate
our large brain. Most species begin to walk in a few days. Human babies don’t achieve
this level of self sufficiency for a year or more. Belonging and bonding is a matter of life
and death, a visceral fact and never forgotten.
Babies observe and mimic adult gestures and later behavior. Matching modeled
behavior wins smiles, hugs and implicit praise – bonding and belonging. Not matching is
frowned upon - rejection.
As each accepting-belonging and rejection-abandonment gesture is registered in the
developing brain a cultural image of self begins to emerge. Constantly gazing in the
mirror of relationship, the baby is drawn and shaped by its interpretation of approval and
rejection. The mature self-image is no different. Who we think and feel we are is not
what we really are, rather it is, most often, a reflection of how we experienced our
behavior being accepted or rejected by others.
Nature’s wisdom runs deep. She assumes that the adult has mastered his or her
environment. For the young mimicking the adult’s mastered response is a quick recipe
for survival. That is nature’s design and it worked for millions of years.
50,000 years ago, more or less, something changed. The new brain (neocortex) grew
dramatically and with it came adult behaviors based on abstract beliefs rather than
concrete sensory experiences, pleasure and pain, and the feelings these experiences
generate, affection and fear. Patterns of knowledge, belief, and behavior were based on
symbolic thought and social learning; in a word, culture emerged. And with that
emergence the bonding-belonging survival reflex, approval and rejection, and most
importantly the self-image spawned by this reflex, began to reflect abstract cultural
values, beliefs and behaviors. We began bonding to culture as much or more than to
people, the behavior of people in this sense expressing and representing a particular
culture. And all of this has been taking place beneath the level of our conscious
awareness for centuries.
The curious thing is the way the bonding-survival reflex acts upon cultural beliefs
morphing them into our self image. Attack Christianity and a Christian feels personally
assaulted. You may place your life in danger denouncing a particular name or color in a
gang infested neighborhood. Cultural images and beliefs have a way of seeping onto
our personal identity. It is really not a mystery. That is the way our personal image of
self was created and this curious fact is the source of centuries and centuries of insane
and violent behavior. And it is here that hope for real transformation rests.
Like corporations cultures, once created, take on a life of their own. Individual people
come and go but the dominate forms that make up the culture remain. This would be
great if the forms that make up a culture were based in wisdom and true intelligence.
But they are not.
Intelligence is a state of the body and mind - not a belief. Emerging from this state
insights may surface and become beliefs but those beliefs are not intelligence. In order
to maintain any connection to their original source fixed beliefs must constantly be
dipped in the living pool of intelligence and be born again and in new ways that are
appropriate to this moment rather than the past. But they are not.
The Inquisition was an act of culture, not wisdom or intelligence, and it lasted over 300
years. More bloodshed and violence has been born out of culture and belief than any
natural cause. And we and our children are bonded to that - culture.
Culture is the context upon which our feeling approved of or rejected is based. Who we
think we are, the self-image we justify and defend throughout life, is a reflection of
culture. And culture uses this image to modify and control our behavior by manipulating
our deep need to belong. This is done primarily through organized religion, compulsory
schooling and mainstream parenting – all of which are again, most often, handmaidens
of culture rather than one’s deep wisdom or innate intelligence.
Remember the early studies on imprinting. At a given point, very early in life, baby
ducks would line up and follow anything that moved. Nature assumed that the leader
being followed was mother and a duck. Researchers substituted themselves at this
critical moment and baby ducks imprinted to the researcher rather than to the mother.
New human beings would do the same if wisdom and innate intelligence provided the
mirror in which they saw themselves rather than the prejudices and taboos of culture.
Yes – babies must belong, they must bond - but to what, the implicit and growing
madness that culture represents, the Arab and the Jew, the Christian and the Hindu, the
Republican and the Democrat, the black, the white, and the gangs and nationalism?
Isn’t that what organized religion, compulsory schooling and mainstream parenting do –
bond our identity to this madness?
Look at what we have done and are doing. Every break in our bond with life, with
nature, increases our feeling of isolation, depression and even rage, and each of these
adds to culture’s coffers, its influence in our lives. The majority of pregnancies are
unplanned. Technological birth, the buzzing sounds, flashing lights, the gloved
strangers coming and going, synthetic substitutes for nature’s hormones injected that
neutralize any hope for a natural ecstatic birth and the bonding that shared ecstasy
promotes lifelong. Womens’ liberation generated billions in new taxes but did nothing to
support mothering, quite the contrary, it separated by design entire generations of
infants from their mothers, placed them in government certified programs, early and
extended childcare, often supervised by complete strangers. That sounds good for
bonding.
The shared meaning of storytelling was replaced by commercial television. Today’s
children have more eye contact with violent television characters than their own parents.
Company sponsored competitive sports replaced original play. Face book replaced
slumber parties. Halloween is now hosted at shopping malls rather than the neighbor’s
hours next door. Every Child Left Behind, standardized testing and constant
comparison, producing chronic anxiety throughout the nation in children, parents and
teachers, now routinely imposed in preschool – and a thousand other insidious ways –
each of these threaten us, causing us to seek the deeper bonds we don’t have. Not
finding this fundamental bond with life, with wisdom and innate intelligence we turn to
the only bonds we have – the counterfeits culture offers.
So I ask you again, Bonding to What?
Imagine for a moment another imprint, another bond, a bond to innate intelligence and
wisdom rather than this culture or that. What you would find, if this were an option, is no
self image at all. When challenged, rather than returning to fixed images and beliefs of
self and other, we would return to the deep well of intelligence and from that source find
a response that is appropriate – now.
Remember, intelligence and wisdom are states of the heart, body and mind, not ideas,
images or beliefs. Seeing this clearly one understands that returning to this source
requires no image of self, no approval of others. In fact, one can’t touch true intelligence
if the image is there. The presence of the culture image in the system fundamentally
alters the system. One nail drives out another.
On close examination it is plain to see that we are much more that source than the false
and limited images culture would have us believe. Seeing that we are not what we think
we are is the tipping point. From that moment forward we as adults begin reflecting to
our children something entirely different than the cultural mask we have been so
comfortable wearing. In that moment the false bond to culture is broken and our true
humanity surfaces naturally.
Looking out at the world, at humanity, at the people we love and especially our children
from this state, free from cultural images and beliefs, in that moment we and the world
are born again and not a moment too soon.